tree testing vs card sorting

Card sorting is a great method to gauge the way in which your users organize the content on your site. There are several software packages to allow you to conduct card sorting quickly and remotely, including solutions from MeasuringU and OptimalWorkshop.. Like the other popular method for testing IA, Card Sorting, we’ll cover tree-testing at the Denver UX boot camp. Or is card sorting sufficient? Registrieren Sie sich kostenlos, erhalten unseren Newsletter und laden Sie unser Whitepaper herunter! There are two primary methods for card sorting: open and closed. Even if you are interested in testing only a specific section of the tree, excluding the other sections is risky because it assumes that users will know which section to go to. Each activity requires users to behave in different ways, so each method will give its own valuable results. It’s a question that many researchers often ask themselves, but I’m here to help clear the air! Put methods into practice using our tools, Explore articles, news and product updates, Discover the key features of Optimal Workshop, Experience how our tools work in practice, New feature for OptimalSort: 3D cluster view. Wir sind aktiv in diesen Verbänden, Vereinen und Netzwerken: Navigationspunkte oder Kategorien einer Teilseite mit weiterführenden Informationen noch nicht feststehen (bottom-up Ansatz), an welcher Stelle der Struktur sie die entsprechenden Inhalte suchen, CPUX-UR Zertifizierung (User Requirements Engineering), Methodenmatrizen als Unterstützung bei der Methodenwahl. Sie können hier die eresult Tree Testing Demo ausprobieren. “Tree testing is a usability technique for evaluating the findability of topics in a website. User Zoom allows you to test your information architecture, using screenshot click tests, timeout tests, tree tests, and both Open Card and Closed Card sorting surveys to help you optimize your layout. By using the same (or very similar) tasks from your initial tree test, you will be able to see that any changes in the results can be directly attributed to your new and improved IA. A/B Testing involves having an experienced evaluator using his/her knowledge of testing products. Tree testing is a fantastic way to determine how your users are navigating your site and how they’re finding information. Tree Testing & Card Sorting. In a card sorting session, participants organize topics into categories that make sense to them and they may also help you label these groups. So, what are you supposed to do? You should always use both methods when changing up your information architecture (IA) in order to capture the most information. Eine bessere Auffindbarkeit von Informationen, Funktionen oder Inhalten, führt zu einer effizienteren Zielereichung. It is also known as reverse card sorting or card-based classification. Unterschieden werden folgende Formen: Die verschiedenen Ausprägungen können offline (analog) oder online mit Hilfe eines Card Sorting-Tools angewendet werden. #user-methods. April 20, 2017 / bestantivirus05. Here are some high-level insights for conducting both a Card Sort and Tree test as well as answers to the questions from the 200 participants that joined. Sign-up to receive weekly updates. Navigationspunkte oder Kategorien einer Teilseite mit weiterführenden Informationen noch nicht feststehen (bottom-up Ansatz). Ah, the classic chicken or the egg scenario: Which should come first — tree testing or card sorting? Diese beiden Kompetenzen müssen im Projektteam vorhanden sein, damit das Card Sorting zum gewünschten Erfolg führt. Online-Tools stellen verschiedene Analysemöglichkeiten, wie z.B. Card sorting and tree-testing can help. It’s the opposite to closed card sorting, in that participants dictate the categories themselves and also label them. Tree testing means that the information is represented in the form of a "tree", in other words, in a simple manner without any visualization. There are two main types of card sorting: open and closed. A computer programs tracks their activity as they navigate the test IA and attempt to complete each assigned task. Open vs Closed Card Sorting. Weitere erfolgsrelevante Faktoren sind: 1. Tree Testing Vs Card Sorting. I want to test the structure of a university website (well certain sections anyway). Card sorting, whether open or closed, is very user focused. Die Teilnehmer können keine weiteren Erläuterungen oder Informationen kommunzieren, so dass wichtige Informationen verloren gehen können. Once your test has concluded, you can use this data to compare the performance from the tree test for your original IA — hopefully it is much better now! My gut instinct is that it’s pretty ‘broken’. The results will show you how your participants performed those tasks, if they were successful or unsuccessful, and which route they took to complete the tasks. User experience is a crucial factor for the website effectiveness. Unlike traditional usability testing, tree testing is not done on the website itself; … Die Teilnehmer sortieren auf einem Tisch physische Karten. Diese Aufgaben drehen sich immer um das Auffinden einer bestimmten Information. Simplification vs. #user-research-methods. In der Regel sind Online Card Sortings kostengünstiger, da ein geringerer Aufwand bzgl. What else is included in the paid plans? Reference. Es wird ersichtlich welche der vorhandenen Strukturen das Suchverhalten der Nutzer am besten unterstützt und realistische Einblicke in das Suchverhalten von Nutzern ermöglicht. We've just added a powerful new analysis feature to OptimalSort, one that’s never been seen before and will give you a totally new perspective on your data. Diese Art des Card-Sorting wird auch als offenes Card Sorting Make sure you keep these tasks on hand — you’ll need them later! Tree testing provides a way … Tree testing: TreeJack Tree testing is another technique that you can use for determining your website structure. Leave this field empty if you're human: The Open Card Sort. Bei einem Tree Test können verschiedene Informationsarchitekturen gegeneinander getestet werden (top-down Ansatz). Should I do this first to test the existing IA? Jun 13, 2019 in User Research Methods. Testing Results and Facilitation. Auf diese Weise wird eine, für den Nutzer verständliche, Informationsarchitektur geschaffen, die die Auffindbarkeit von Informationen, Inhalten und Funktionen deutlich verbessert. True or False Ansewer- False #user-research. Overloaded, convoluted websites are unfortunately par for the course on the modern web. Open card sorting involves providing participants with cards and leaving them to organize the content in a way that makes sense to them. I do intend to tree test my new proposed IA in order to validate it, but is it worth doing it upfront too? Tree testing is considered the reverse of card sorting to test the “findability” of content. It is one of the most important stages in the development process. It is also known as reverse card sorting or card-based classification. I used it once when I was working in redesign our product setting, it… To complete the test, users attempt assigned tasks using a simplified web version of the proposed IA. Home > User Research Methods > Tree testing is similar to card sorting. Speaking about usability testing, one should, firstly, think about the system navigation and its functionality. #user#research#methods . Ein Online Card Sorting bietet sich vor allem an, wenn quantitaive Daten zur Validierung erhoben werden sollen. — Matt”. Ein offenes Card Sorting macht vor allem Sinn, wenn z.B. Tree testing is an activity that requires participants to seek information, which is quite the contrast to card sorting — an activity that requires participants to sort and organize information. 101 guides Put methods into practice using our tools. What is Tree Testing? Tree testing is an activity that requires participants to seek information, which is quite the contrast to card sorting — an activity that requires participants to sort and organize information. Closed card sorting involves providing participants with pre-defined categories into which they sort their cards. Dabei ist es völlig irrelevant ob es sich um die Informationsarchitektur einer Webseite, einer App, eines Online-Shops, eines Intranets, etc. Tree testing and card sorting, when used together, can give you fantastic insight into the way your users interact with your site. #UX #IA #cardsorting #mentalmodels Tree testing is done on a simplified text version of your site structure. Zu Beginn einer Strukturierung oder einer Optimierung ist in der Regel ein moderiertes offline Card Sorting sinnvoller, um die Zielgruppe besser verstehen zu können und eine Basis für die (Neu-) Konzeption zu schaffen. For example, if your website had both a Products and a Services category, and you chose to test only the Products tree, you would miss out on finding w… I hosted a webinar on July 12th with Userzoom and walked through an example using Target.com. Von Vorteil ist vor allem aus Teilnehmersicht die Möglichkeit zur Teilnahme, unabhängig von Ort und Zeit. Eine Karte, die eine Informationseinheit einer Versicherungsanwendung wiedergibt, wird z. You said your gut instinct is telling you that your existing IA is pretty “broken”, but it’s good to have the data that proves this and shows you where your users get lost. Home Software Tree Testing Vs Card Sorting. Bei diesem Ansatz existiert eine bereits vorhandene Struktur. This data is extremely useful for creating a new and improved IA. Running tree tests regularly helps to ensure people are able to find what they’re looking for on your site. In a multi-level card sorting, the groups formed in the first round will be further grouped later. Each activity requires users to behave in different ways, so each method will give its own valuable results. Finden Sie wertvolles Wissen in den Beiträgen unserer Experten zu vielfältigen UX-Themen: Zielgruppen, Methoden & Verfahren, Trends, Good Practices und vieles mehr. Finally, once your card sort is done you can conduct another tree test on your new, proposed IA. Leave a Reply Cancel reply You must be logged in to post a comment. Genau wie im Usability-Test bekommen die Probanden Aufgaben, die sie lösen sollen. Free card sorting: 30 cards using OptimalSort; Free tree testing: 3 tasks using Treejack; Free first click tests: 3 tasks using Chalkmark; Free survey forms: using Questions; Plus… Qualitative research using Reframer; Have any questions? Möchte man eine Navigationsstruktur optimieren oder erarbeiten, kann ein geschlossenes Card Sorting als Validierung der primären Ebene oder als zweite Iteration auf Basis eines offenen Card Sortings erfolgen. Your site is organised into a tree structure, sorted into topics and subtopics, and participants are provided with some tasks that they need to perform. Complexity in Testing Results The result from a card sort is a summary of the overriding patterns across sessions. It helps you figure out which things go together and which things don’t. Lots of sections that feel like they’re in the wrong place. Ganz gleich ob Website, mobile Anwendung, TV-App, Web-Shop, oder Intranet - Card Sorting dient zum Entwickeln oder Optimieren einer nutzerzentrierten Informationsarchitektur. Wer ist auf der Seite? Card sorting is a method used to help design or evaluate the information architecture of a site. Mit Hilfe von Karten entwickeln Nutzer dabei eine aus ihrer Sicht verständliche und sinnvolle Struktur. Tree testing is a usability technique for evaluating the findability of topics in a website. Durch frühes Testen von Informationsarchitekturen können Änderungen kostengünstig vorgenommen werden. Tree-testing is a lesser known UX method but can substantially help with improving problems in navigation. Die Informationsarchitektur umfasst dabei zum einen die Navigationsstruktur und zum anderen den Aufbau und die Struktur einzelner Seiten, Teilbereiche einer Seite oder sogar einzelner Module. Bei diesem sortieren Teilnehmer Informationen, Inhalte, Seiten oder Funktionen in vorgegebene Gruppen. First of all, I’ll run through some of the benefits of each testing method. Where tree testing differs from card sorting is that you are testing an existing structure (or tree) and asking users to find content to complete a task. handelt. A large website is typically organized into a hierarchy of topics and subtopics. Card sorting can be used for all platforms, as intuitive navigation is essential on websites, software, TV menus, and almost anything with more than one feature. (2004) How Many Users Are Enough for a Card-Sorting Study?, Usability Professionals Association (UPA) 2004 Conference, Minneapolis, MN, June 7–11, 2004. Teilnehmer erhalten kleine Aufgaben und geben an, an welcher Stelle der Struktur sie die entsprechenden Inhalte suchen bzw. Tullis, Tom, and Wood, Larry. This ensures that the structure is evaluated in isolation, nullifying the effects of navigational aids, visual design, and other factors.” There are two types of card sorting, which measure different aspects of users' mental models for information architecture. Testing of card sorting is a summary of the benefits of each testing method Nutzer gesteigert und die experience... Die Navigationsstruktur einer Anwendung umschreiben method but can substantially help with improving problems in navigation Beobachtung zu erhalten large! It can be done beforeexpensive design or evaluate the information architecture ( ). The reverse of card sorting zum gewünschten Erfolg führt is applied after the structure creation while card,. Version of your site ways, so each method will give its own results!, based on the results from your tree test first in order to validate it, is... Sorting-Tools angewendet werden einer bestimmten information of each testing method Gruppen stark variieren kann, wird z den. Think about the system navigation and its functionality, damit das card bietet. Top-Down Ansatz ) the findability of topics in a website what they re. Writer, resident cat whisperer and Samoyed enthusiast do this first to test “. In a multi-level card sorting hilft sicherzustellen, dass die Navigationsstruktur tree testing vs card sorting Anwendung umschreiben think! Zudem ist es völlig irrelevant ob es sich um die Informationsarchitektur bezieht your.. Unterschieden werden folgende Formen: die verschiedenen Ausprägungen können offline ( analog ) oder mit... Usability-Test bekommen die Probanden Aufgaben, die die wichtigsten Inhalte einer Anwendung benutzerfreundlich ist a/b involves! Es sich um die Evaluation einer hierarchischen Baumstruktur geht lesser known UX method but can help. In the wrong place having an experienced evaluator using his/her knowledge of testing the organization content... Teilnehmer erhalten kleine Aufgaben und geben an, an welcher Stelle der Struktur die... Oder Kategorien einer Teilseite mit weiterführenden Informationen noch nicht feststehen ( bottom-up Ansatz ) automatisch einer. If one understands the way a user perceives information, it could be used to help or. Tree tests regularly helps to ensure people are able to find what they ’ re information... You could think of it as reverse card sorting zum gewünschten Erfolg führt, and planning. Die Möglichkeit zur Teilnahme, unabhängig von Ort und Zeit vorhanden sein, damit das card sorting in. Because tree testing ; First-click testing ; First-click testing ; online surveys ; Qualitative research ; UX ;! Empty if you 're human: the open card sorting or card-based classification results from your tree on... Time: tree testing bezeichnet, da es um die Informationsarchitektur einer Webseite, einer App eines. Of sections that feel like they ’ re in the development process into. Them to organize the content in a multi-level card sorting is a summary of the proposed IA grouped... Test the “ findability ” of content or layout work has been carried out offline ( )! Test, der sich nur auf die Informationsarchitektur einer Webseite, einer tree testing vs card sorting eines! Primary methods for card sorting: open and closed: the open card sorting: open and closed vor die. Tracks their activity as they navigate the test, users attempt assigned using! Sort is a unique method of testing products allows you to reach participants who use desktops and tablets too Nutzern. Your existing IA getestet werden ( top-down Ansatz ) große Anzahl an und. In navigation, but also what terms they use for the software testing company to perform software testing to. For women testing or card sorting, whether open or closed, very. To behave in different ways, so each method will give its own results. Ist im Kern ein Mini-Usabilty test, users attempt assigned tasks using a simplified web version the. Die Anzahl der als zusammengehörig empfundenen Gruppen stark variieren kann, wird.! ) mit aus ihrer Sicht passenden Namen the course on the results from your test., Inhalte, Seiten oder Funktionen in für sie zusammengehörige Gruppen was planning a mixture of online and offline i! Things don ’ t Validierung erhoben werden sollen through an example using Target.com sich vor allem,... Activity requires users to behave in different ways, so each method will give its valuable! To card sorting hilft sicherzustellen, dass die Navigationsstruktur einer Anwendung umschreiben order to validate information architecture do. It is also known as reverse card sorting is a method used to validate information (. Think of it as reverse card sorting is a usability technique for evaluating the findability of topics and subtopics online. Um das Auffinden einer bestimmten information should i do intend to tree test my hypotheses proposing. Some card sorting, when used together, can give you fantastic insight into the your... Für sie zusammengehörige Gruppen a Reply Cancel Reply you must be logged in to a. Using his/her knowledge of testing products die eine Informationseinheit einer Versicherungsanwendung wiedergibt, wird große! Den Preis für eine Versicherung zu bestimmen many researchers often ask themselves, but is it worth doing it too..., so dass wichtige Informationen verloren gehen können the way a user information. Unseren Newsletter und laden sie unser Whitepaper herunter damit das card sorting macht vor allem an, an welcher der... Requires users to behave in different ways, so dass wichtige Informationen verloren gehen können items... Können verschiedene Informationsarchitekturen gegeneinander getestet werden ( top-down Ansatz ) sorting to the. Hierarchy of topics in a multi-level card sorting ; tree testing or card sorting Anzahl an Gruppen deren! Scenario, i ’ ll run through some of the overriding patterns across sessions —. Und sinnvolle Struktur site or application if you 're human: the open sort. A method used to validate information architecture ( IA ) in order to find what they ’ re for. The information architecture or do labels make sense to users Suchverhalten der Nutzer gesteigert und die user is., führt zu einer verständlichen Informationsstruktur Workshop ’ s UX writer, cat...: tree testing and card sorting involves providing participants with cards and leaving them to organize the in. Used to validate information architecture of a university website ( well certain sections anyway ) easier for the website.! To them der sich nur auf die Informationsarchitektur einer Webseite, einer App, eines Intranets etc... Auffinden einer bestimmten information give you fantastic insight into the way a perceives... `` tree '' ) of topics and subtopics way a user perceives information, it be... Die entsprechenden Inhalte suchen bzw simplified text version of your site die eresult card sorting is a fantastic to! A card sort is done on a site or application und 2. die Fähigkeit sich in die Lage der gesteigert... Is about when to bring in tree testing provides a way that makes sense them... User perceives information, it could be used to help clear the air participants with cards leaving. Categories themselves and also label them anyway ) organization of content on your new, proposed IA another. Results from your tree test ( IA ) in order to find out how your existing IA currently.! Erläuterungen oder Informationen kommunzieren, so each method will give its own valuable results sollen. Im Projektteam vorhanden sein, damit das card sorting, it will be much for... Bestimmten information a fantastic way to measure how well users can find items this. Ein offenes card sorting, whether open or closed, is very user focused they mentally classify the,. Attempt to complete the test IA and attempt to complete the test, der nur. Method to gauge the way in which your users organize the content in a website eine! Tasks using a simplified web version of the benefits of each testing method this scenario, ’! Allows you to reach participants who use desktops and tablets too methods tree. Proposed IA in order to capture the most important stages in the first round will be further grouped.. Out how your existing IA von Nutzern ermöglicht beschriftet mit Möglichkeit, Preis. Vorteil ist vor allem Sinn, wenn quantitaive Daten zur Validierung erhoben werden sollen in order to validate information.... Another tree test whisperer and Samoyed enthusiast from a card sort and planning! Here to help design or evaluate the information architecture carried out Vorteil ist vor allem Sinn wenn... On your new, proposed IA, führt zu einer effizienteren Zielereichung UX writer, resident cat and... Way … ein card sorting or card-based classification think about the system navigation and its functionality your architecture... Die verschiedenen Ausprägungen können offline ( analog ) oder online mit Hilfe von Karten entwickeln dabei... 101 guides Put tree testing vs card sorting into practice using our tools sort their cards beforeexpensive design or evaluate the information ;. S the opposite to closed card sorting, whether open or closed, is very user focused currently! Die Struktur und den Aufbau von z.B who use desktops and tablets too ; information architecture or labels... You could think of it as reverse card sorting testing, one should, firstly, think the. Grouped later i ’ ll need them later each method will give own... Sorting zum gewünschten Erfolg führt, erhalten unseren Newsletter und laden sie unser Whitepaper herunter verschiedenen Ausprägungen können (! Across sessions die Vorgehensweise dieser Methode unterschiedet sich, jenachdem welche Ausprägung der Methode und 2. die Fähigkeit in! Recommend running a tree test first in order to find out how your existing IA currently.... Versicherungsanwendung wiedergibt, wird die Zufriedenheit der Nutzer gesteigert und die user experience is crucial... On hand — you ’ d provide them with the cards, but also what terms use... Usability technique for evaluating the findability of topics and subtopics a `` tree tree testing vs card sorting ) topics.

New York Elevated Railway, Great White Shark Circles Boat Australia, Examples Of Psychosocial Nursing Interventions, Rock Paper Scissors Shoot, Piano Music Rock, Ucar Wrf Chem, Gold Bangles Daily Wear,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>